2014 NHL Draft Weekend Trade Analysis

Michael Dal Colle (via NewYorkIslanders.com)

Michael Dal Colle (via NewYorkIslanders.com)

Size up the 18 year olds and put the FOR SALE stickers on the vets, it’s time for the 2014 NHL Entry Draft. The floor is now open to make deals.

The 2014 NHL Draft was shocking in the sense that nothing shocking really happened. Aaron Ekblad was taken by the Florida Panthers after hours of trade speculation *COUGH*TORONTO*COUGH*DREGER*COUGH* surrounding the first overall pick. The top-5 were essentially everyone’s top-5, and the top-20 went as predicted.

Garth Snow drafted seven players. He took LW/C Michael Dal Colle, the projected/assumed 5th overall…5th overall. He then used two of his 2nd-round picks to snag the 28th overall pick to go with highly skilled wild card Josh Ho-Sang. Two goalies, a defenseman, and two more centers later, Snow has added pieces to the cupboard. I had him moving the 5th and having no firsts for two consecutive drafts, and instead he snagged that late first this year to cover his bases. Sound moves to position himself well in this draft, especially with the acquisition of another 1st-rounder this year.

Outside of the drafting, the trade front was a bust in the face of such an array of players who have been gossiped about since February. Kesler moved but not Spezza. No Evander Kane trade. No self-immolation by teams looking to get under the new $69M salary cap.

All trades will be analyzed with two metrics:

– Clear winner on paper
– The Garth Scale

The Garth Scale measures the (non)-impact Garth Snow had on this deal, ranging from five (no fault/couldn’t be involved) to zero (fireable offense).

Here’s the recap of player-based transactions.


To NY Islanders: 2014 28th pick
To Tampa Bay: 2014 35th and 57th picks (both 2nd-Rd)
Winner – NY Islanders
Garth Scale: 5/5

Snow used his best movable assets to get a second 1st-Rd pick to make up for the loss his 2015 1st.

To NY Islanders: 2014 and 2015 7th-Rd Picks
To Tampa Bay: 2014 7th-Rd pick
Add another piece to next year’s draft. Fine with that


To Anaheim: Ryan Kesler (C), VAN 2014 3rd-Rd Pick
To Vancouver: 2014 24th pick, ANA 3rd-Rd Pick, Nick Bonino (C), Luca Sbisa (D)
Winner – Anaheim
Garth Scale: N/A

Vancouver had been dealing with this for a while. Kesler wanted out but his NMC (to only Chicago or Anaheim) bound the hands of new Canucks GM Jim Benning. It was the Jarome Iginla situation on repeat. Vancouver gets a 2/3 center with some upside, a 1st-Round pick, and a living human. Both players give Vancouver cap friendly deals while the Ducks now have Getzlaf-Kesler at center, and that’s kind of scary in spite of Kesler’s loss of speed and recent injuries. Anaheim is now more prepared to take on LA and Chicago in the playoffs. Can’t wait for the gold medal/silver medal rivalry to make things interesting.

To Tampa Bay: Jason Garrison (D), Jeff Costello (LW), VAN 2015 7th-Rd Pick
To Vancouver: 2014 50th pick (2nd-Rd)
Winner – Push/No one
Garth Scale: 4/5

Garrison goes back to the Sunshine State. He had a NTC but this could have been an NHL defenseman with decent size the Islanders need. This is a salary dump, ultimately. While Garrison is physical that’s his only asset. Wonder what his criteria for going to Tampa was. Costello is a college prospect.

To NY Rangers: 2014 85th Pick (3rd-Rd)
To Vancouver: Derek Dorsett (RW)
Winner – NY Rangers
Garth Scale: 5/5

You don’t trade with the Rangers, especially for a 3rd-line nothing. Crazy Vancouver.

To Nashville: James Neal (RW)
To Pittsburgh: Patric Hornqvist (RW), Nick Spaling (C)
Winner – Nashville
Garth Scale: 3/5

No idea who Nick Spaling is, Hornqvist can pot a few, but Neal is a sniper. Jim Rutherford clearing house yet got reasonable value for an absolute douche bag. Unless Neal had any sort of No-Move, Josh Baliey could have replaced wither piece in the deal. Then again, Rutherford may not have wanted to trade within the division and get burned multiple times a year.

To Vancouver: Linden Vey (RW)
To Los Angeles: 2014 2nd-Rd Pick
Winner – Vancouver
Garth Scale: 4/5

Vey was lost in the shuffle of LA’s forwards and needed a change of scenery.

To St. Louis: Carl Gunnarsson (D) and 2014 4th-Rd Pick (and Toronto retains $200K of salary)
To Toronto: Roman Polak (D)
Winner – St Louis

Roman Polak is the “physical stay-at-home” defenseman Toronto loves. Gunnarsson no longer has to be a Leaf. Same old Toronto.

To Calgary: Brian Bollig (LW)
To Chicago: 2014 3rd-Rd Pick
Winner – Umm…

Chicago dumped a bad contract and got a mid-level pick in return. Calgary gets a good character guy and former St Lawrence Saint, to play 3rd and 4th line minutes.

To Washington: Eddie Pasquale (G), 2014 6th-Rd Pick
To Winnipeg: 2014 6th and 7th-Rd Picks, 2015 7th-Rd Pick
Winner – Leaning towards Washington

Winnipeg stockpiled picks and Washington has another goalie for the pipeline to be molded by new Capitals goalie coach Mitch Korn. Anytime you can have a young goaltender under Korn’s watch it’s a good day.

So a good weekend for Garth Snow and a generally boring day for the rest of the league.

Now begins the wait for July 1st at noon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s